logo

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa

Every stockbroker charges a fee for performing the trading deals. Moreover, these fees can be different for different asset classes. It is important to choose the best stock broker for your trading needs to maximize the return on investment.

Please find below, a very detailed comparision report for the stock brokers, A G Shares Securities and 5Paisa . The comparision table below helps you to compare A G Shares Securities and 5Paisa in various aspects.

You can find how A G Shares Securities and 5Paisa stack up when brokerage charges, trading platforms, customer support, complaints and more are compared.

Also, you can visit A G Shares Securities brokerage calculator and 5Paisa brokerage calculator for a detailed report on brokerage charges.


Overview

Let's start with the differences. A G Shares Securities is a Private company while 5Paisa is a Public company. A G Shares Securities was founded by Ajay Kumar Agarwal in 1995. A G Shares Securities has it's headquarters at Agra, Uttar Pradesh. 5Paisa was founded by Nirmal Jain & Rajamani Venkataraman in 2007. 5Paisa has it's headquarters at Mumbai, India.

Also, A G Shares Securities is a Full Service Broker. In general, full service brokers provide more investment advice and perform detailed stock analysis for their clients. The brokerage fees are also towards the higher side. On the contrary, 5Paisa is a Discount Broker. As the name suggests, discount brokers carry out buy/sell orders at a lower commission rate. In general, they charge a fixed brokerage fee. Investors can save a lot of money that they otherwise need to pay to a full-service broker. To know more about discount brokers, please visit Discount brokers in India .

Overview A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Broker Type Full Service Broker Discount Broker
Type of company Private Public
Headquarter Agra, Uttar Pradesh Mumbai, India
Founders Ajay Kumar Agarwal Nirmal Jain & Rajamani Venkataraman
Foundation Year 1995 2007

A G Shares Securities and 5Paisa Trading Account Opening and Demat Charges

Demat (short for dematerialization account) account is used for holding securities in electronic form, and the securities are deposited through National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL) or Central Depository Services Limited (CDSL).

The account opening charges vary from 0 to Rs.200 for various brokers such as A G Shares Securities charges Rs.200 whereas 5Paisa charges Rs.650.

Once you have opened a Demat account, you have to pay certain charges such as account maintenance charges, broker commission, GST, STT. The AMC (Annual Maintenance charges) are around Rs.300, and the discount broker usually charges Rs.20 per executed trade as their commission.

˝ As mentioned above that the CDSL and NSDL are both depositories registered by the Indian government to hold securities such as stocks, commodities, bonds, ETF's in electronic form or copies, and different brokers use one of the two depository types. A G Shares Securities uses CDSL & NSDL while 5Paisa uses CDSL.

Account Opening and Demat Charges A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Trading Account Opening Charges Rs.200 Rs.650
Demat AMC (Annual Maintenance Charges) Rs.300 per Annum Rs.400 per Annum
Trading AMC (Annual Maintenance Charges) Free Free
Margin Money Minimum Rs.10,000 Zero
Offline to Online Charges Yes Not applicable
Depository CDSL & NSDL CDSL

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Equity Brokerage Charges

Apart from the AMC charges, an investor also has to face other charges for using different services by the broker.

Other Brokerage Charges

Equity delivery charges: This basically means that you hold the securities for a certain amount of the time in your Demat Account and sell it at the right time to make a gain on your investment. As the competition is really high for brokers in this area, they usually charge Rs.0 for equity delivery to attract more customers, while some charge up to Rs.20 per executed trade. A G Shares Securities charges 0.20% for equity delivery and 5Paisa charges Rs. 0 for equity delivery.

Equity Intraday: As the name tells, equity intraday means buying and selling of stocks/shares within the same day. A G Shares Securities charges 0.02% for equity intraday and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for equity intraday.

Equity Futures: This term means buying and selling shares at a fixed price on a future date. A G Shares Securities charges 0.02% for equity futures and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for equity futures.

Equity Options: They allow an investor to buy or sell stocks under a set or strike price through a contract (1 contract = 100 shares). A G Shares Securities charges Rs.20 per Lot for equity options and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for equity options.

Equity Brokerage Charges A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Equity Delivery Brokerage 0.20% Free
Equity Intraday Brokerage 0.02% Rs.20 Per Order
Equity Futures Brokerage 0.02% Rs.20 Per Order
Equity Options Brokerage Rs.20 per Lot Rs.20 Per Order

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Currency Brokerage Charges

Many discount brokers are providing their services in India right now. Still, not all of them are trading stocks, currency, and commodities. However, those who are the top-performing ones do provide their services in these areas with separate charges.

Currency future: This term is also commonly known as FX future or foreign exchange future. As the name suggests, it's a future's contract to exchange one currency for another currency at a specific future date at an exact or fixed price at the purchase date. This concept is similar to that of equity futures. A G Shares Securities charges 0.02% for currency futures and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for currency futures.

Currency Options: As with equity options, a currency option is a contract that gives a buyer the right (not obligation) to buy or sell a particular currency at a fixed exchange rate on or before a specific date. A G Shares Securities charges Rs.20 per Lot for currency options and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for currency options.

Currency Brokerage Charges A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Currency Futures Brokerage 0.02% Rs.20 Per Order
Currency Options Brokerage Rs.20 per Lot Rs.20 Per Order

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Commodity Brokerage Charges

Commodity trading: The textbook definition of a commodity is a raw material or primary agricultural product that can be bought or sold. In the world of trading, this concept is prevalent. Many traders buy or sell gold, silver, and oil, and many brokers are providing their services online to ease this process of buying and selling raw materials. A G Shares Securities charges 0.02% for commodity trading and 5Paisa charges Rs.20 Per Order for commodity trading.

Commodity Brokerage Charges A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Commodity Options Brokerage 0.02% Rs.20 Per Order

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Other Charges

Other brokerage charges that an investor should keep in mind are

Minimum broker charges: A G Shares Securities charges Percentage of Transaction as minimum brokerage charge. 5Paisa charges Rs.10 as minimum brokerage charge.

Transaction brokerage charges: These are charges that a customer face on every transaction completed by DP (depository participant) A G Shares Securities charges 0.00315% as transaction brokerage charges. 5Paisa charges 0.00325% of Total Turnover as transaction brokerage charges.

SEBI Turnover charges: Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is the regulator of the security and commodity market. It keeps a check on fair trade for all investors and charges a certain amount for their turnover. A G Shares Securities charges 0.0002% of Total Turnover as sebi turnover charges and 5Paisa charges 0.0002% of Total Turnover as sebi turnover charges.

Stamp Duty charges: Stamp duty charges vary depending on the state and the type of asset class.

GST Charges (Goods and Services Tax): A GST of 18% on brokerage and transaction charges is applied.

STT (Securities transaction tax): A G Shares Securities charges 0.0126% of Total Turnover as STT and 5Paisa charges 0.0126% of Total Turnover as STT.

Other Brokerage Charges A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Minimum Brokerage Charges Percentage of Transaction Rs.10
Transaction Brokerage Charges 0.00315% 0.00325% of Total Turnover
SEBI Turnover Charges 0.0002% of Total Turnover 0.0002% of Total Turnover
Stamp Duty Charges As per the state (Use A G Shares Securities Brokerage Calculator to see report) As per the state (Use 5Paisa Brokerage Calculator to see report)
GST Charges 18% of (Brokerage + Transaction Charges) 18% of (Brokerage + Transaction Charges)
STT Charges 0.0126% of Total Turnover 0.0126% of Total Turnover

A G Shares Securities vs 5Paisa Equity Exposure/Leverage

Exposure relates to the amount of money an investor has invested in a particular trade/stock and the amount he can lose on that trade/stock. Leverage links with exposure; if an investor wants to increase his exposure on a specific trade/stock, he can use leverage to take a much bigger position on the trade with his broker's help. Leverage of 1:500 means that for every $1 or Rs.1 of their share capital, the trader receives $500 or Rs.500 to trade with. This concept is expected in stock and forex trading, and many brokers provide even more than 1:500 leverage to attract more customers to use their services and trade through them.

Equity Leverage A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Equity Delivery Upto 2X Upto 5x
Equity Intraday Upto 7X Upto 35x
Equity Futures Upto 3X Upto 8x
Equity Options Upto 5X Upto 12x

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Currency Leverage

Currency Leverage A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Currency Futures Upto 3X Upto 6x
Currency Options Upto 2X Upto 10x

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Commodity Leverage

Equity Leverage A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Commodity Upto 3X Upto 10x

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Offers

Many stockbrokers are providing attractive offers to capture more customers. These offers are as follows:

Free Stock Trading and Demat Accounts: many brokers offer new investors to open an account free to cost and start trading straight away with them.

Flexible Plans: attractive plans at an economical price such as ProStocks monthly plan targeting equity cash and currency F&O at Rs.899 and Rs.499, respectively.

Brokerage discounts: Coupons providing up to 50% discount at their rates.

Happy Hours: A specific time slot where the trades/customers get brokers' services at a discount.

1-month free plan: where brokers provide free delivery trading such as OneTradePlus.

Holiday offers: brokers are providing their services at a discounted rate on special events such as Diwali.

Referral Program: brokers provide a discount when your family or friends sign up with the broker using your referral code.

Zero Brokerage on loss trade: complete refund of money on unsuccessful trades.

Offers A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Free Stock Trading Account Yes Yes
Free Demat Account No No
Flexible Plans No No
Brokerage Discounts Yes Yes
Happy Hours No No
1 Month Free Plan No No
Holiday Offers Yes No
Referral Program Yes No
Zero Brokerage on Loss Trades No No

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Features

Apart from attractive and catchy offers, many stockbrokers provide services that are appealing to investors and traders. The services are as follows:

  • Mutual Funds: helping investors build their long term investment portfolio for maximum return and minimum risk after performing proper fundamental and technical analysis.
  • Forex: many stockbrokers are not only providing their services in the stock market sector but also in Forex.
  • Banking: full-service brokers are also providing their services in the banking sector.
  • SIP (systematic investment plans); this is a branch that falls under a mutual fund's services, many brokers help investors shape their investment portfolio systematically for maximum returns.
  • Insurance: Top performing brokers even provide insurance plans for their clients.
Features A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Equity Delivery Trading Yes Yes
Equity Intraday Trading Yes Yes
Equity Futures Trading Yes Yes
Equity Options Trading Yes Yes
Currency Trading Yes Yes
Commodity Trading Yes No
IPO (Initial public offering) Yes Yes
Stocks Suggestions Yes No
Robo Advisory No Yes
PMS (Portfolio Management Services) No No
Trading Institution No No
Trading Exposure Upto 7X Upto 35x
Mutual Funds Yes No
SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) Yes No
Forex Trading No No
Banking No No
Insurance No No

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Advisory Services

The main difference between a discount and a full-service broker is the services they provide and the rates at which they are providing.

Discount brokers execute buy and sell orders at a relatively lower commission rate than a full-service broker. Apart from this, a discount broker does not have the skill set to provide in-depth investment advice and analysis on specific stocks and does not have good knowledge of the price-action strategy compared to a full-service broker. All these factors are a significant reason for the difference in their prices.

Fundamental Reports: It is basically the reports related to the analysis of a company's financial statements, which helps the investors and financial analysts to decide regarding the current financial standing of a company.

Research Reports: It is prepared by a financial analyst who is working in hedge funds, investment banks, and mutual funds, and these reports may target a specific company's stock, commodities, currency, or industry.

Company Reports: Company reports are comprehensive and easy to understand reports regarding the company's activities throughout the year, month, or week.

Annual Reports: A branch of a company's report in which a company includes all the activities they have carried out in the previous years and the cost of carrying out those activities and the corresponding profit or loss made while carrying out those activities.

Company Stock Review: Stock review or analysis is comparing the company's financial statements with the previous years. This process also includes analysis of specific ratios such as liquidity ratios, free cash flow ratio, profitability ratio, etc., to get a clear picture of how a stock is performing currently and how profitable a company can be in the future.

Free Stock Tips: Some stock tips for you

  • - Read financial magazines such as Bloomberg, The Economist.
  • - Never get emotionally attached to your investments.
  • - SMS alerts for upcoming IPO's
  • - Invest in company's you believe will have an impact on the world in the next 5-10 years, e.g., Tesla
  • - Use proper risk management.
  • - Diversify your portfolio (choose stocks that are from various industries in order to avoid correlation between them)

IPO reports- A private company go public to increase their funding. This process is done by investment banks, hedge funds by releasing the company's IPOs (initial public offerings).

Top Picks- Top pick stocks are usually the best-performing stocks in a specific year, and it makes it easier for the investor to make an investment call. Some of the top-performing stocks are:

  • Bharti Airtel
  • Nocil
  • Infosys

Daily Market Review: This term focuses on the daily movements and changes in the stock index and tells how many points the index is up or down.

Monthly Reports: Monthly reports are brief yet comprehensive reports focusing on the activities that took place within the month in the company and are used for short term decision making by managers.

Weekly Reports: Weekly reports are summarized reports of the weekly activities in the business and the company's cost to carry out those activities. These reports are used for short term decision making.

Offline Advisory: Advisory is not provided over the internet but by other means such as letters, SMS, and phone calls.

Relationship Manager: The main role of a relationship manager in the banking sector is to deal with the clients and help them make the right decisions, and explain all the firm's financial services in detail.

Features A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Fundamental Reports No No
Research Reports No Yes
Company Reports No No
Annual Reports No No
Company Stock Review No No
Free Stock Tips Yes No
IPO Reports Yes No
Top Picks Yes Yes
Daily Market Review Yes No
Monthly Reports Yes No
Weekly reports Yes No
Offline Advisory Yes No
Relationship Manager Yes No

A G Shares Securities vs 5Paisa Trading Platforms

A trader can use different trading platforms to analyze various stocks/currency pairs/commodities and execute buy or sell orders through that platform. There are Desktop platforms such as MetaTrader 4 for Windows and Android phones and MetaTrader 5 for Mac computers and Apple IOS devices. They are commonly referred to as MT4 and MT5. Standard software is TradingView providing its services in both the stock and Forex sectors with a highly optimized user interface. Their interactive charts make it easy for the traders to perform various types of analysis on the charts.

You can link TradingView and other online platforms like these with your cell phone to get real-time updates and SMS alerts for stocks that are on your watchlist. Moreover, these platforms also provide personalized advisory and give you buy or sell signals when an opportunity comes.


A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Desktop Trading Platforms

Desktop Trading Platforms A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Windows Yes Yes
Mac Yes Yes
Desktop Browser No Yes

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Mobile Trading Platforms

Mobile Trading Platforms A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Mobile Browser No Yes
Android App Yes Yes
iOS App Yes Yes
Windows app No No
Other mobile os No No

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Customer Support

Customer support is a crucial factor that makes a new customer into a loyal and long-term customer. As the world of trading is speedy, an investor needs proper customer support from their brokers to execute orders at the right time to avoid any potential losses. The brokers' responsibility is to be active on live chats, E-mails, helpline numbers, and discussion forums.

Customer Support Features A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
Relationship Manager No No
Offline Trading Yes No
Online Trading Yes Yes
24 * 7 Support No Yes
Email Support Yes Yes
Chat Support No No
Toll free number No No
Support Branches 11 Zero

A G Shares Securities vs. 5Paisa Customer Complaints

To keep a strict check and balance on fair-trade opportunities for every trader and investor, BSE and NSE actively take complaints and resolve them. Investors can lodge complaints about trading members, brokers, and companies listed on the index. BSE and NSE take action to resolve them by giving them a specific time to rectify their mistake, and if not rectified, serious measures are taken against them. Find below the total number of complaints lodged in bse or nse. Also you can find how many of those complaints were resolved. The percentage of lodges vs. resolved cases can also be a useful metric to judge a stock broker.

BSE Complaints A G Shares Securities 5Paisa
BSE Complaints 13 98
BSE Resolved Complaints 13 86
Percentage of resolved BSE complaints 100.00 % 87.76 %
NSE Complaints 19 236
NSE Resolved Complaints 19 230
Percentage of resolved NSE complaints 100.00 % 97.46 %
BSE/NSE Complaint vs. Resolved Percentage 100.00 % 92.61 %

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Is A G Shares Securities better than 5Paisa ?

    A G Shares Securities is a full service broker, while 5Paisa is a discount broker. A discount broker generally charges a flat brokerage for trades. A full service broker generally charges more than a discount broker but provides more research and advisory services. Depending on the costs and trading platform features involved, you can choose the best stock broker for you.

  2. Is 5Paisa better than A G Shares Securities ?

    A G Shares Securities is a full service broker, while 5Paisa is a discount broker. A discount broker generally charges a flat brokerage for trades. A full service broker generally charges more than a discount broker but provides more research and advisory services. Depending on the costs and trading platform features involved, you can choose the best stock broker for you.

  3. Is A G Shares Securities cheaper than 5Paisa ?

    A G Shares Securities is a full service broker, while 5Paisa is a discount broker. A discount broker generally charges lower brokerage fees for trades. A full service broker generally charges more than a discount broker but provides more research and advisory services.

  4. Is 5Paisa cheaper than A G Shares Securities ?

    A G Shares Securities is a full service broker, while 5Paisa is a discount broker. A discount broker generally charges lower brokerage fees for trades. A full service broker generally charges more than a discount broker but provides more research and advisory services.

  5. Which is better 5Paisa vs. A G Shares Securities ?

    To find out the better of the two stockbrokers A G Shares Securities and 5Paisa, compare them based on brokerage charges, trading platforms, Demat account opening fees, research, advisory services, etc.


Compare A G Shares Securities with other stock brokers

Visit the following pages to see a detailed comparision report of A G Shares Securities with other brokerage firms.


Compare 5Paisa with other stock brokers

Visit the following pages to see a detailed comparision report of 5Paisa with other brokerage firms.